Saturday, September 30, 2017

96. Return to Scotland, A Trip of a Lifetime, September 1-21, 2017, Part I

Return to Scotland, A Trip of a Lifetime, September 1-21, 2017, Part I
In the past two years, Pat has gone to Great Britain…in 2015 to the Cotswolds and 2016 to go to the Chelsea Flower Show in London.  I was not invited on either trip and was forced to do my best to find something to do.  In 2015 that meant playing 27.5 different courses (half course being a nine holer) over a period of 24 days (Pat joined me for the last 7 days of the trip and we were rained out at Royal Porthcawl…it was pouring and I had played it decades ago, otherwise I for sure would have been out there).  In 2016, I had to play 16.5 courses in 11 days, and then flew back home with Pat.

This year, Pat decided to go on a tour of castles and gardens near Edinburgh for 6 days…so I of course scheduled a 21-day trip (18.5 courses), leaving 8 days before Pat and then having Pat join me for the 5-6 days of golf after her tour.  She subsequently decided to head across the pond with me and join me for the first 8 days of golf.  And, our good friends from Toronto (whom we know from Pinehurst) John H. and his wife Cathy C. decided to join us (and at times just me) for the last 2 weeks of the trip.

Prior to this trip, I had visited GB&I for golf on some 17 trips totaling about 130-140 days and played 97 different golf courses. Being almost 73 years old, one does not know how long before the legs give out…so I decided to treat this trip as if it was my final trip to Scotland.  I listed four courses I had not played, five that I had only played once, and eight old great ones that I certainly wanted to play for potentially the last time.  Before I knew it, I had an itinerary with 19 courses on it, including 5 of the 14 that have hosted an Open Championship. 

We flew to Glasgow with a change in planes in Dublin and arrived the morning of Saturday, September 2.  After a short drive south to our hotel in Troon (it was way too early for our room to be ready), we headed further south to Trump Turnberry for our first round of golf of the trip (interestingly, Pat and I were at Turnberry in July 2008; it was our last stop on our honeymoon).

Trump Turnberry Resort and Golf Club-Ailsa, September 2, 2017:  Originally opened in 1906 and designed by Willie Fernie, Turnberry and its luxury hotel served as an airbase and military hospital during both World Wars.  The Ailsa course was restored by Mackensie Ross and reopening in 1951 and has hosted the Walker Cup in 1963, the Amateur Championship 4 times, the Senior Open Championship 7 times, the Woman’s Open Championship in 2002, and The Open Championship four times:
o   in 1977 (the Open which made Turnberry famous) which became known as “The Dual in the Sun” between Tom Watson and Jack Nicklaus and they went head to head for the last 36 holes playing brilliant golf (and leaving the rest of the field in their wake) with Watson victorious by a single stroke;
o   in 1986, won by Greg Norman for his first of two Open wins;
o   in 1994, won by Nick Price; and
o   in 2009, won by Stewart Cink in a playoff against 59 year old Tom Watson…in what was almost one of the greatest moments in sports history.

Donald Trump purchased the resort in 2014.  He immediately put architect Martin Ebert to work on a renovation of the Ailsa.  Put simply, the results are brilliant.  I probably had played Ailsa at least 5 times previously, and while it was always a superb course, its conditioning was always “not quite right” and it had several awkward holes…in particular #9 and #18.  Ebert shortened the par 3 6th hole, which allowed the 18th be become a straight away 485 yard par 4 headed straight inland towards the iconic hotel (previously, the 18th used a tee from Turnberry’s second course which resulted in an awkward hole with too sharp of a dogleg left).  He also converted the par 4 9th into a 248 yard par 3 over a deep gorge to a green set slightly above tee height and over a long gorge.  This eliminated a questionable 9th…even with its spectacular drive...and made it possible to change the 10th into a 565 downhill par 5 with a superb green setting.  Other holes with major improvements are 8, 11, 14, and 17.  The Ailsa now plays to a hefty 7489 yards from the tips (par 71…and most likely as a par 70 for an Open).  It is both a very tough course and a very fair course.  IMO it will make a superb Open venue.
View down Turnberry's #18 toward hotel...see wind whipping Scottish flag!


Ailsa has appeared on every World Top 50 and 100 list I have found (43 to date in total), and had been as high as #3 on UK’s Golf World in 2010 and #5 on Top100golfcourses.com in 2011.  Golf Magazine’s 2017 list (release in early September) placed it at #16 worldwide, well up from its #23 in 2015.  My own personal opinion would place it around #12 worldwide.  And for those of you who claim I only rate highly the courses on which I play well, please note that I had a smooth 45-47 = 92…which may have been influenced by some jet lag, and strong southerly wings (20-25mph).

We did not stay in the hotel but heard it is now quite the place…and the lighthouse is now converted into a luxurious room and half-way house for the course (the latter is considerably cheaper than the former which is rumored to go for about $5,000/night).
Pat and moi on 9th tee with lighthouse and 9th green (far right of pic)


After the round we had a quick dinner at Turnberry and drove back to Troon…it was great to get to bed!!  Note the pic below…our room at The Troon Marine Hotel was the same room occupied by Arnold and Winnie Palmer when he won The Open at Troon in 1962.

Outside our room at Troon Marine Hotel...where the King stayed in 1962

Western Gailes Golf Club, September 3, 2017:  Western Gailes is about 7 miles north of Troon along Scotland’s west coast and lies right next to the same commuter train line that runs alongside Troon’s 11th hole and Prestwick’s 1st.   It was founded in 1897 and has a long history as a qualifying site for The Open Championship and hosted a Curtis Cup Match in 1972.

I had played Western Gailes once before in 1981.  A few years prior, the club had rebuilt holes 3-5 having lost the land that housed the original holes 3-5 to make way for a new road at the north end of the club.  At the time there was almost no vegetation alongside these new holes and they looked completely out of place.  Somehow, 36 years can make quite a difference.  Today, these holes look they have been there since 1897. 

The layout of WGGC is very simple…the property is a long thin sliver of land between the Irish Sea to the west and the commuter railway line to the east.  The clubhouse lies on the eastern edge and holes 1-4 head north (to the right as you exit the rear of the clubhouse), then holes 5-13 head south, and 14-18 back north.  The prevailing wind is out of the south (as it was this day), the stretch from 5-13 seems to never end and tests the golfer’s stick-to-itiveness.  WGGC plays to 7014 yards from the back (par 71).

The weather this day was awful.  The weather all trip was not great and this day was the worst.  It rained for about 13-14 of the 18 holes and the wind blew at about 15mph in mid-50’s temps.  Pat had the brains to stay back at the hotel…but as most of you know, good judgment is a rare commodity in my brain.  After a solid par on #1 it was downhill from there and I finished the day with an 89.  These were very tough conditions and this is a very tough course.  Additionally, true links golf is tough to get used to….and while I have played a fair amount in my lifetime, playing it only occasionally is not the same as living here.  The lies are very very tight, and you need to know how the land moves in detail because the game here is played mostly on the ground (as opposed to in the air in the USA).  The greens and fairways are very firm and the ball can run and run and run (especially with the wind)…so when hitting to the green, you need to understand the shape of the ground from 10-20 yards short of the green all the way to the cup…does, it move up or down, left or right?  It takes a bunch of rounds to gain and retain that knowledge.

Best holes are probably:
 #6--a short par 5 of 498 yards, turning right off the tee to create a fabulous Cape driving holes to a tight fairway (much less room right than it seems on the tee) and a tough approach to a deep (38 yards) narrow green (at one point 7 yards wide);
#7—198 yard par 3 alongside the Irish Sea; another deep (31 yards) green that is very narrow up front (9 yards wide) and guarded by 6 bunkers;
#17—470 yard par 4 turning left; tee shot must thread fairway bunker left and railway line right…then approach is blind over a long dune cutting diagonally across fairway.
Overall this is a great, tough, fair golf course, which unfortunately is overshadowed by its more famous neighbors along the west coast (Prestwick, Troon, and Turnberry).  Well worth a visit if you are on the west coast.

St. Andrews, The Old Course, September 4, 2017:  When I first started planning this trip, September seemed to be the ideal time.  I later learned (too late to make a change), that September is the worst time if you want to play The Old Course and/or Muirfield.  The R&A holds their Fall Meeting in September and other important golf organizations hold major events in Scotland in September as many of their members/participants are planning to go to the Fall Meeting.  As a result, available “slots” at The Old Course and Muirfield are much more limited.  While I was able to schedule times at both, I was very fortunate to be able to do so, and the dates meant that Pat could not join me and/or required long drives to get there and back.   The Old Course looked truly impossible until I was introduced to Simon Holt from Connoisseur Golf, an agency that packages high end trips to Scotland.  Simon is trying to finish a World 100 list and we had talked a couple of times about his remaining courses, etc.  He lives in North Berwick and belongs to North Berwick GC, but his official office is in St. Andrews.  When I asked him about the possibility of playing The Old Course, he was not encouraging but later contacted me to advise that Connoisseur had a threesome scheduled to play it 9/4 at 1pm…with room for as 4th.   That was before Pat decided to leave on 9/1 instead of 9/9.  So when she decided to go over with me, we knew she could not play TOC that day.

We left Troon around 8:30am and arrived about 11:15 for lunch with Simon.  I had hosted him back in June at Brookline and he is just a great guy.  Loves the silly game of golf and makes a living at it while arranging fabulous trips for other golfers…what could be better?  We arrived at the first tee around 12:30 and hung out in anticipation of our start.  There I met my three playing partners, two from Calgary and one from Vancouver…all good guys.  I have been fortunate enough to play TOC about 10 times (first time in 1970), and trust me…it never never gets old.  There is no feeling in the game like teeing off in front of the R&A on the #1 tee…except the feeling one gets putting out on #18!! 

After a good drive on #1, I dumped 6-iron into the Swilken Burn for a double, then settled down and played well on the rest of the front nine, until fading on the back to a 41-44 = 85.  There were three pieces of good news.  First, I started making crisp contact with most of my long shots, and started putting well…and I parred both 17 and 18 which made me feel great.  Pat walked the town and later caught us as we were playing 17.  The round was interrupted about 3 times by rain squalls but the weather was much improved from Sunday.

On the Swilken Bridge off 18th tee with me bride...last time here July 4, 2008.  Smiling because am with her (and my par on 17).

I presume I don’t have to list TOC’s championships or World 100 rankings.  But to put it simply, it has hosted:
            29 Open Championships
            16 Amateur Championships
            8 Walker Cup Matches
            1 Curtis Cup Match
            1 Senior Open Championship (2018)

World Top 100’s:
            All 43 lists…two placed it #1, 18 (of 41) placed it in top 5, 35 (of 41) placed it in top 10, and 42 placed it in top 15…never lower than #20.

This course had no original architect, is (IMHO) the most important course in history in terms of architecture (it represents the definition of strategic architecture), is almost as flat as a pancake but the land is wonderfully rumpled, been played by every great professional and amateur player in the history of the same except Ben Hogan, has hosted more men’s majors than any other course save Augusta National, is simply fun and a joy to play, takes dozens of round to start to understand, continues to confound some of the best players in the world without being tricked up...and does all of the above after several centuries of play!!  Simply amazing and truly unbelievable!!

Others have described individual holes better than I ever could…and this information is readily available on the web…so go research it, or better yet, make the trek and play it.  You will most likely hate it at first, but it is an amazing experience.

After the round, Pat and I had dinner at a wonderfully simple Italian restaurant in town…Little Italy…well worth a visit.

And then we had a 2:20 drive back to Troon…not fun but worth every second!

Prestwick Golf Club, September 5, 2017:  Unfortunately after a long day on Monday, we had a tee time at 8:30 at Prestwick Tuesday morning (as we had a flight out of Glasgow airport at 5:10pm that evening).
 
Prestwick GC was founded in 1851.  For those of you who are not aware, Prestwick hosted the first 12 Open Championships from 1860-72 (was not played in 1871…more later) and then an additional 12 times (24 in total) with the last time being 1925.  Prestwick’s original course contained 12 holes, and was expanded to 18 holes in 1883. The Open, crowds, and all the logistics involved (even then) had outgrown Prestwick’s limited space. 

After our round, the Club’s Secretary, Ken Goodwin was kind enough to show Pat and me around the clubhouse and afford us the opportunity to view some of the original scorecards and other artifacts from early Opens.  When the Open was first played in 1860, the winner was awarded possession of the Championship belt for one year…with the belt being permanently awarded to any person winning the Open three consecutive years.  After Young Tom Morris did just that in 1868, ’69, and ’70, the Open was cancelled for 1872 until another award could be developed.  As an aside, in 1870 (still using the 12 hole course), Young Tom Morris played the first hole…578 yards in length…in three strokes using hickory shafts and gutta-percha balls.  Think about that for a minute or two.

The Gold Medal first was awarded to Young Tom Morris when he won again in 1872 (and has been awarded to the winner every year since).  In 1873 the “Claret Jug” (officially known as the Golf Champion Trophy) was first awarded to the winner (although Young Tom Morris’ name is also engraved on it for his 1872 victory).

Prestwick organized the Open until 1871.  The funds for the Claret Jug were paid jointly by Prestwick Golf Club, The Royal and Ancient Golf Club of St Andrews, and The Honourable Company of Edinburgh Golfers (Secretary Goodwin showed us the actual invoices between these clubs), and these three clubs administered The Open from 1871 through 1920, when the R&A took over total responsibility for the event.  From 1872-93 The Open rotated between the home courses of these three clubs (The Old Course, Prestwick, and Musselburgh…until The HCEG moved to Muirfield in 1892).  In 1894 the Open was held in England for the first time at St. George’s GC (today’s Royal St. George’s GC).

Those of you who wish to know more of the history of golf in Scotland between 1850 and 1880 or so should read Tommy’s Honour, or see the movie of the same name released earlier this year, or better yet, do both.

Today’s Prestwick plays to 6908 yards from the tips, and is simply a delightful course to play.  I was most pleased to see Prestwick included in Golf Magazine’s World Top 100 this year (at #100) for the first time.  It has been on 13 of the 43 World Top 100 listings I have found, and has consistently been in the 30-35 range on Darius Oliver’s Planet Golf  and was #59 on The Golf Architects survey.  It demands clear thinking, knowledge of the layout (given the 5 or so blind shots), at times precise accuracy, and patience.  For those of you who have been to our home in Pinehurst, the 12th tee at Prestick is the stage for that photo of me at the top of my backswing, in semi-perfect position with Ben Crenshaw looking on.  That photo (which I had blown up as large as it could) might well be included in the world’s largest bonfire Pat is planning should she outlast me…with all my old scorecards and yardage books making up the bulk of the fire.  Brian Morgan…thank you again for that photo!

Our play was interrupted by rain squalls several times again, but we were getting quite good at quickly donning and removing rain jackets!  My start of double bogey/birdie was typical of the round and I ended with a 43-43 = 86.


After the round was the fascinating tour conducted by Ken Goodwin, then off to Glasgow airport for a flight to Islay (one of the islands off Scotland’s west coast) and then drive/ferry ride/drive to the adjoining island of Jura.  More in next post.

Monday, September 25, 2017

95. A Quickie in Connecticut and Massachusetts

A Quickie in Connecticut and Massachusetts

The next day, Pat and I were synchronizing calendars when I realized she was headed up to Essex County Club on Monday and Tuesday August 28 and 29 to play in a Member-Guest with her good friend Jill B.  Essex is a wonderful club and course and is about 30-35 miles from our house, but would be a real hassle to go back and forth from Milton each day…so she was going to stay up there Monday night so I started planning a mini trip for the following Monday and Tuesday.  As I was just playing 3 courses and had a good idea of which ones I wanted to play…and was not attempting Shinnecock, National, etc etc., I actually got it done with a few calls and emails.  Plan was to leave around 9am on Monday 8/28 and drive to Fairfield CT to play Country Club of Fairfield, then play Tamarack CC in Greenwich CT the morning of 8/29 and then drive to just north of Springfield MA to play Orchards GC the afternoon of 8/29…and then drive home.
 
Country Club of Fairfield, August 28, 2017:  Located right along Long Island Sound.  CC of Fairfield was founded in 1914 and the club hired Seth Raynor to build the course.  Due in large part to World War I, the entire project was not completed until 1921.  In later years, A. W. Tillinghast and Robert Trent Jones, Sr. oversaw renovations to Raynor’s original work.

I had played CC of Fairfield two other times, the first in 1990, and always loved the feel of the club and course.  It sits right next to the small boating harbor in Southport, CT and as such it “feels” like a course setting one might find in the British Isles.  Interestingly though, the only course that I have ever seen in the British Isles with such a feel is The Island Club, just north of Dublin, Ireland.
 
I actually played from the “tips”…not a big deal as the course is only 6374 yards from all the way back, but it is a gem of a course and wonderfully fun to play…and on windy days it can be a bear (but this day was fairly calm).  It is the type of course that makes you want to play another 18 holes as you finish your first round.  It has always played fast and firm and is generally revered by golf architecture affectionato’s.

I did not play particularly well, shooting a 41-42 = 83.  The course and club were very quiet and the clubhouse was closed (this being a Monday).  Best hole is the 9th which is a “Redan” hole, a 196 yard par 3 build on top of a hill with a sharp drop off to the left of the green.
Redan #9 at CC of Fairfield

From 2006-08 CC of Fairfield made the GW merged USA Top 100, peaking at #93 in 2006.  In 2013 and 2015 it was included on GM’s USA Top 100 with a high of #95 in 2013 (but was not included on GM’s 2017 list released about 2 weeks ago).

After the round I went down to Greenwich (stayed there) and got some good sleep.  Had a tee time at just before 8am on Tuesday morning at Tamarack.

Tamarack Country Club, August 29, 2017:  In my years playing golf in the NY area (mostly in Westchester County as an adult), I had heard of Tamarack but frankly the message was always “decent course but not worth a special trip” (it sits about 3 miles from where I lived from 1988-2005).  Over the past year or two, I had heard word from several other Panelists that it was now something special, so I scheduled it for this trip to take a look-see.  That was a smart move.

Tamarack CC was founded in 1909 and its current golf course was designed by Charles Banks and completed in 1929.  Just as Seth Raynor was a protégé of C.B. Macdonald, Banks was a protégé of Raynor.  Like Macdonald and Raynor, Banks’ courses feature a number of the famous “template” holes that are adaptations of some of the great holes in the British Isles.  Banks earned his nickname “Steamshovel” because of his tendency to move prolific amounts of dirt to create dramatic holes.  However, over time and like many of the classic great old courses, Tamarack had become over treed, lost many of its distinguishing bunkers, and slowly had its massive greens shrink (from changing mowing patterns, especially during WWII when fuel conservation was essential).  Noted architect Brian Silva proposed a Master Plan which was fully implemented a few years ago.

I arrived at the club a little early and had a chance to spend some time with head pro Bobby Farrell.  The Farrell family is one of the NY area’s great golfing families.  Bobby’s grandfather, Jimmy, won the1928 US Open conducted at Baltusrol in NJ and also served as head pro from 1919-1930 at Quaker Ridge GC in Scarsdale, NY, my home club from 1975-2000, and later became head pro at Baltusrol.  His son (and Bobby’s father) Billy was head pro at Stanwich CC in Greenwich CT from 1964-2000.  But the coolest thing is that Bobby is head pro at a course where his grandfather played in the first foursome to play Tamarack when the course opened in 1929.

While I never saw Tamarack before Silva’s restoration, no question that it is an excellent course today…the CB Macdonald/Seth Raynor/Charles Banks DNA is clearly obvious throughout the 18 holes, but especially on the Cape (#2), Eden (#3), Bottle (#4), Redan (#7), Punchbowl (#11), Biarritz (#12), Road (#14), and Short (#15) holes….see pics below of #3 and #7.
Tamarack #7 Redan-187 yards- from right back of green---super sharp slope from  right side
Tamarack #3 Eden hole---184 yards...go over and it is over!
Tamarack plays to a healthy 6846 yards (par 70 from the back) and is in excellent condition (although I would prefer to see it a little firmer and faster and less green).  I had a 41-42 = 83, same score as at CC of Fairfield.  It has never been on w USA Top 100, but is certainly moving up in other ratings (#5 in GD’s CT best in state).  It is something special but not quite Top 100 material…except perhaps GW’s Top 100 Classics.  It is well worth a visit.

After the round, had another chance to talk with Bobby, thanked him and was off to MA where Orchards GC awaited.

Orchards Golf Club, August 29, 2017:  Located just north of Springfield MA, the Orchards GC started with 9 holes designed by Donald Ross and Ross added another 9 holes in 1927.  In 1941, the course was donated to Mount Holyoke College.  It plays from the tips at 6575 yards.  The course has a strong record of hosting important events, including:

            1987 USGA Junior Girls’ Championship
            1994 MA Boys Junior Boys Championship
            2001 MA Amateur Championship
            2002 NCAA Woman’s Championship
            2004 USGA Woman’s Open Championship (won by Meg Mallon).

Frankly, the course is now over treed and is fairly poor condition.  I would assume that its conditioning is not as high priority for Mt. Holyoke College.  I had a 42-45 = 87 and had trouble keeping my interest up.


After the round I made great time back to Milton MA.  It was Tuesday evening, Pat had returned from a fun time up at Essex with Jill and we had to get moving on packing for our trip to Scotland (leaving three days later on Friday afternoon).  Good thing I never over schedule!!!!

Sunday, September 24, 2017

94. WI Finale to Crazy Trip

WI Finale to Crazy Trip
Flight from Reno to LV went well but we were delayed by a minor equipment issue on LVàMilwaukee flight.  Eventually arrived around 40 minutes late and then faced long line at car rental counter, so ended up about an hour late getting to Blue Mound which is northwest of the city.

Blue Mound Golf & Country Club, August 24, 2017:  Over the past 2-3 three years I had started to hear very special and very positive rumblings about Blue Mound.  I learned that it was a Seth Raynor design, and one of his last courses before his untimely passing…and that it had been beautifully restored.  Additionally, earlier this year I met a BMGCC member who is a fellow member of CCNC, Mark R., whose opinions I respect, who advised that I needed to see it (unfortunately for me, Mark was traveling on golf business on 8/24). 

I pulled into the club’s very hidden entrance around 4:10pm and soon was looking at one of the great clubhouses built in the 1920’s…very much reminding me to Country Club of Detroit, Detroit GC, The Park (Buffalo), Mountain Ridge (NJ), and Winged Foot.  I entered the pro shot and had wonderful conversation with head pro Barry Linhart…a wonderful, and engaging gentleman.  During this conversation, I learned that the concept of a restoration of BMGCC arose during a visit by the late George Bahto, a NJ dry cleaner who became the world’s foremost expert on the works of C. B. Macdonald and Seth Raynor.  Bahto looked at what apparently was an overgrown, overtreed, soft, wet course with greens that had shrunk over the years and asked the principals and leaders of the Club: “Do you know what you have here?”  As they say, the rest is history.  Bruce Hepner led the Renaissance (Tom Doak) Golf team that did the renovation.

By 4:30 I was in a cart and headed to the first tee.  The layout here is similar to Muirfield, Quaker Ridge, Onwentsia, etc. with the front nine circling the property (in this case clockwise) and the back line inside the front nine.  As I approached the first tee, I could sense my adrenaline rising…the course looked and felt magnificent…and greeting me at the first tee was the following statue of my favorite architect:
 
Raynor sculpture off first tee
I will try to be brief in describing BMGCC…but please note, as good as it is…Camargo in the Cincinnati area is still my favorite inland Raynor.  First the par 3’s…there are four and they cover the four best par 3 templates and are superb: Biarritz (#3 with the swale in front of the green), Short (#7); Redan (#13); and Eden (#17).  Other great template holes are Alps (#4), Road (#5), Punchbowl (#8), Cape (#11), and Leven (#16—which did me in).  The course is in superb condition and very firm and fast. 

From the tips, BMGCC now plays to a relatively short 6666 yards…but that is plenty of length for 98% of club players.  My adrenaline was pumping every minute of the round and I shot a solid 39-41 = 80.  It hosted the 1933 PGA Championship (won by Gene Sarazen).  In terms of Top 100’s it has never made a list.  Having discovered this “Hidden Gem” it is time to get it known to the golfing world!  And one more final thought on Milwaukee…this city (once an industrial powerhouse) is home to two great old tracks/clubs…the combination of Milwaukee CC and Blue Mound G&CC represents a pair of great ones often unrecognized (or even unknown) by the golfing world (and…quite frankly, by moi, before seeing them, for the first time in 2013 and 2017)…plus the superb Lawsonia Links some 90-100 miles to the northwest.  Yes, the new great ones of Sand Valley, Erin Hills, and Whistling Straits (but excluding Irish Straights which I hate) generate much publicity…but forget not the above mentioned threesome of old great ones that provide the base!
Abundant low quality photographs follow:
Blue Mound clubhouse from the golf course


2nd shot on 497 yd par 5 5th hole (Road Hole)--see Road Hole Bunker just in front of green

Slightly uphill approach shot from behind cross bunkers on Road Hole...better view of Road Hole Bunker

445 yd par 4 Punchbowl #8 from the tee...sharply uphill and slight turn left to green

 
Approach shot on #8 Punchbowl

Green on #8 Punchbowl with my ball behind pin...just before I sunk my 7' birdie putt!!  (ball on front right of green was  practice shot I hit after after my first approach shot with 3-utility)

185 yard par 3 #13 Redan Hole

Redan hole from behind...catch that shape on the green from golfer's right (from left side of pic)
355 yd #16 Leven Hole green from back right--I hit my 8 iron approach over ---and  quick double bogey ensued
191 yard Eden par 3 #17 from in front of "infinity" green

#17 green falls off in back to this bunker
2nd shot on 560 yard par 5 18th with clubhouse in background



Sand Valley Golf Resort, August 25, 2017:  I left around 7:30pm and headed west and then north heading for the latest Mike Keiser creation…Sand Valley Golf Resort located near Nekoosa, WI, a drive of about 2:30.  All went well until my iPhone GPS application (Apple Maps using GPS data from Tom Tom) left me at the end of an abandoned road that had been used during the construction phrase.  I looked at a signpost with about 4-5 instructions on how to get to the resort from this location and cursed a bit.  About 10 minutes later I had progressed about ½ mile to the resort after wondering if I would meet my demise by getting totally lost around 10pm in northwestern WI.  In any case, I did finally get to my room and got some sleep.  This would be 27 holes…18 on Sand Valley and 9 on SV’s second course…Mammoth Dunes, which is still under construction. 
Had arranged to meet a golfing buddy from Pinehurst and CCNC, Gail K. at SV.  Gail and his wife Sherry are from Minneapolis and belong to Spring Hill GC and Wayzata CC there.  Gail and I had originally planned to do a trip with wives through MN, WI, and MI’s Upper Peninsula some time over the summer, but that fell through given the complexities of all of our travel schedules.  So when I realized that Blue Mound and Sand Valley would be a logistically possible end to this ridiculous trip (and a perfect fit for my remaining bucket list items), I called Gail and he was free for August 25. 
Gail had arrived the afternoon before while I was just arriving in Milwaukee (and had similar issues finding SV) so we met Friday morning for an early breakfast.  We had the second tee time and both play pretty quickly which helped given my (as usual) tight schedule.  The plan was to play the first course, Sand Valley, and then have a quick lunch.  At that point Gail had to head west to the Twin Cities for a dinner party, and I planned to play nine holes on the second course, Mammoth Dunes (still under construction…more later).

For those of you who have been living in a cave for the past 20+ years, Mike Keiser created the first recycled paper greeting card company and sold it about 25-30 years ago for something like $125 million.  By then he had been bitten by the golf bug and wanted to build his own course.  His first effort in this regard resulted in the Dunes Club in SW Michigan (he is from Chicago…about 90 minutes away)…which may be the best 9 holes course and club in the USA.  His second effort is called Bandon Dunes.  If you need to know more, Google his name which will be much easier than my typing more about him.

Keiser has completed the first course (Sand Valley), a clubhouse, lodges and rooms, etc etc.  Coore & Crenshaw designed Sand Valley and it had a soft opening last year and an official opening May 2, 2017.  A second course, Mammoth  Dunes, designed by David McLay Kidd is still under construction (9 holes now open for play) with a projected opening in 2018 for all 18 (a 17 hole...no typo there…par 3 course designed by Coore-Crenshaw is also expected to open officially in 2018).

Sand Valley Golf Course, August 25, 2017:  To my mind, this is another brilliant example of what the combination of Mike Keiser and today’s great architects (Coore-Crenshaw, Tom Doak, David McLay Kidd, etc.) find when they hunt for wonderful natural land just waiting to be discovered.  It is fun, challenging and fair, and when I finished 18 I wanted to play it again.  Filled with wide fairways, angles and options, few if any forced carries, the opportunity (in many cases necessity) to run approach shots into the green, difficult run off areas around the greens, and large difficult greens to putt…it is a classic example of strategic architecture.  To date ratings have been favorable but not overwhelming.  Earlier this year Golf Week had it as #61 on its Top 100 Modern list, which equated to #133 on my GW Merged list (however, it is important to note that all of the play contributing to that rating was from 2016, prior to SV’s official opening).  Golf Magazine last week published its 2017 Worldwide and USA Top 100’s…SV was ranked #52 in the US Top 100, but did not make the cut for the World Top 100 (however, for the first time GM also published the 15 courses that “just missed” and SV came in #111 on that list).

Interesting story on how this place became “Bandon Dunes Midwest”.  In 2012, a Chicago businessman named Craig Halton and his wife were hiking in this part of Wisconsin (about 250 miles from Chicago) and came across this vast expanse of towering sand dunes.  Craig is a golfer and reached out to Mike Keiser, who at first was not high on the idea.  But Keiser did dent one of his lieutenants out to look, and the report came back “you are not going to like this but this place is fabulous” (or something along those lines).  The rest is history as Keiser purchased 1700 acres and now one of the poorest counties in WI is undergoing a boom in tourism, jobs, etc etc.  Interestingly, I am told by a reliable source that Keiser has been surprised by the large number of visitors from Minneapolis-St Paul (3.5 hours away compared with 2.5 hours from Milwaukee and 3.5 from Chicago).  That news did not surprise me at all…Minnesota is like Michigan Massachusetts regarding golf…a relatively short season but the people there who play are dedicated golfers and when it does swarm up in late spring, they get their rounds in while da gettn is good!  A little so-so weather does not hold them back.

The course was in fabulous condition…very firm and fast.  The dunes and waste areas are something to behold.  The par 3’s are a superb collection.  The greens are close to perfect…and fit right into the landscape, as do the fairways.  Stretches to 6913 yards par 72 (5 par 5’s and 5 par 3’s).  And the accommodations, food, etc. and simply outstanding (without being over the top)…just like Bandon and Cabot.  No surprise with any of this…Coore-Crenshaw is IMHO the best architectural firm around, and Keiser has “played this course” before.  He has a “model” for an upscale, great, minimalist golf resort and is simply repeating it brilliantly.


Sand Valley 216 yd #3 Redan in a terrible photo


593 yd par 5 4th uphill to green


4th hole from 5th tee located behind 4th green 
175 yard par 3 #5...downhill to turtleback green and my tee shot fell off the turtle's back


136 yard par 3 #8 to 3 tiered green...amongst the toughest 136 yard holes you will find

563 yard par 5 10th, downhill off tee; stock a 9-iron to about 4' for birdie

View from SV #9 to Mammoth Dunes #6 and #7



I played well with a 41-38 = 79 and no bogies on the par 3’s (had four pars and one double bogey 5)
The only question going forward is “does today’s golfer ever tire of strategically designed (wide fairways, wide fairways with lots of options, firm-fast conditions, big interesting greens complexes) in remote locations?”  I hope not…but stranger things have happened.

Mammoth Dunes, August 25, 2017:  After lunch w Gail, he headed west a few yards and walked over to the first tee of Mammoth Dunes.  A key part of Keiser’s model is to have at least two courses in an area to attract golfers and make the journey to remote locations worthwhile (hence the purchase of 1700 acres).  The second course at Sand Valley Resort is Mammoth Dunes, designed by David McLay Kidd…a Scotland whose initial breakthrough came when he designed the wonderful Bandon Dunes course for Keiser about 17 years ago.  Apparently, over the years since Keiser had grown unhappy with the newer courses designed by Kidd.  Then Kidd designed Gamble Sands in central WA (see blog post from last month) and in exchange for doing a favor for Keiser asked him to go see and play Gamble Sands.  That round put Kidd back on the “A list” and got him this assignment.
Most of the work is done with nine holes open for play (1-5 and 15-18).  The other nine holes (6-14) are in the grow-in phase and are scheduled to open spring 2018 (along with the Coore-Crenshaw 17 hole par 3 course).  These nine total 3674 yards (par 37) but I would guess the completed course will end up around 6900-7000 yards.   Keiser is not trying to build courses to hold majors or PGA Tour events…I think he recognizes that golf has become bifurcated and he is catering to the amateur player and smartly avoiding the “monster” tracks build in the 1970’s and 1980’s.  I also think has a “hedge strategy”, jic.  If my memory is correct, most of the holes on his courses have plenty of room for lengthening should tastes change and/or technology continue to lead to longer and longer shots by players at all levels.

Mammoth Dunes #2 across to hole #1

Approach shot on MD #2 par 4 of 410 yards

MD par 3 207 uphill---great hole


It really is too early to tell how good Mammoth Dunes will be.  The fairways and greens were much slower than SV as the young grass needs time to mature before being closely cropped and rolled.  The word I had heard before my visit is that the Kidd parcel may be a better piece of land than the Coore-Crenshaw.  Again too early to tell but based on the nine holes I played it certainly is more dramatic.  2018 should be an important and interesting year for the Keiser organization.
I ended up shooting a 41 for this nine…and look forward to completing play here in late 2018 or 2019 (assuming the legs are still working).

After thanking the staff, and reconfirming driving instructions, I was off for Milwaukee airport, concluding a tough but highly successful trip.  I again lucked out weather-wise.  In terms of my bucket lists, at this point I stood at:
            --980 courses played to date;
            --50 States--DONE
            --7 more to complete the USA Top 100 EVER (4 from Golf Digest lists and 3 from Golf Week lists…Golf Magazine is done)
            --3 more PGA sites to complete the Men’s Majors EVER
            --2 to complete the “Cups” EVER (Ryder, Presidents, Walker, Solheim, Curtis)
            --1 to complete US Senior Open EVER (British Senior Open EVER done)
            --1 to complete US Am EVER (British Am EVER done)
            --2 to complete US Mid-Am EVER (no British Mid-Am)
            --2 courses to complete the ’16 and ’17 GW Top 100 Classic and Modern.

In total, 17 to go.


Got home a little earlier than expected and fairly tired but the light at the end of the tunnel is getting brighter, and I can’t hear a train coming!!