Chicago, July 17-19, 2017
On July 18 and 19, Pat is
playing at the Sakonnet Invitational in Rhode Island, so it is time for me to
knock off the courses I have left in the Chicago area. Trip planning for this one went fairly
smoothly but the threat of thunderstorms on the last day of the trip started to
grow just before I left…so that was something to keep watching.
On Monday 7/17 I left Logan
Airport around 10:50 for O’Hare…smooth flight and everything went well at both
airports. My trip plan was top play five
courses over the three day span. If the
trip went as planned, I would be finished with Chicago area courses although
would have two courses left within easy driving distance of Chicago (Blue Mound
G&CC in Milwaukee, WI, which hosted a PGA Championship, and the Warren
Course at Notre Dame in South Bend IN, which will host the 2018 US Senior
Open). I also planned to visit Ruth Ann
P. who had by then completed her initial chemotherapy treatment and was
scheduled for her second on 7/19.
Black Sheep Golf Club, July
17, 2017: Black Sheep is located some 55 miles west of
downtown Chicago, deep into IL farm country.
Designed by David Esler, it opened in 1999 and consists of 27 holes
(numbered 1-27). Black Sheep is an all men’s club (one of four
in Chicago…others being Bob O’Link, Butler National and Old Elm). It has been a regular on Golf Week’s USA
Modern Top 100 since 1995 (peaking at #53 in 2006), but never high enough to
make a GW merged Top 100. It debuted as
#157 on the merged list in 2005 and then was #118 (its highest rating) in 2006. After steadily declining to #152 by 2013, it
moved back up to the low 120’s thereafter…most recently #124 in 2017.
Its setting is very special
as the local farms present a fabulous backdrop and the land had just about the
right amount of movement. Its design is
certainly strategic (wide fairways with angles being critical). Course was in excellent condition and was
firm and fast (although the greens were slightly slower than I expected). Areas between holes have no trees (only one
on the entire 285 acre property—see picture below) but lots of native grasses
that did not seem to be fescue…as almost all of it was very green as opposed
golden. While I liked the basic design,
I thought the bunkers should be deeper and golden fescue would be much more striking
visually.
Black Sheep's lone tree |
I loved the “sense” of the
club…very low key, no swimming pool, housing, etc., just pure golf.
I caught it on a very calm
day for the Windy City, and I would guess that Black Sheep would be a tough
test in more typical conditions. I played
from 6463 yards, par 72 (on holes 1-18) which is about 400+ yards longer than
normal for me, but shot a 38-42 = 80.
When I arrived at the par 5 6th hole and saw it played 583
yards from my tees, I wondered how I could ever reach it. It turns slightly right and is basically
flat. Anyhow, after a very good drive
and two well hit 3-woods, I was pleased to see my third shot scamper onto and
then about 12” into the back fringe of this hole (got down in two from there
for my par). My guess is that is the longest
par 5 that I have reached in regulation in about 8-10 years (btw, whatever wind
was blowing was with me)! My sense is
that this is about a top 150 course in the USA.
After the round I drove into
Chicago to visit Ruth Ann who seemed to be doing well, especially given the
treatment she is undergoing. RAP’s
sister Pam was in from Phoenix to help out and it was great to see her as
well. RA had quit smoking 37 years ago! Made me want to thank Richard Ardern, good
friend from business school who bet me a beer I couldn’t go from Friday
afternoon to Monday first class without a cigarette in September 1967…on Monday
morning I agreed to a “double or nothing” until the next Friday, and haven’t
touched one since. Thank you, Dick!!!
After dinner with RA, I drove
about 30 miles north to my hotel…my other 4 courses on this trip were all north
of the city (regular readers will recall that I played the great courses south
of the city, Flossmoor and Beverly, back in mid-May of this year.)
Started to worry about weather
for Wednesday…had 36 holes scheduled and a late flight back to Boston…if I
could play 54 Tuesday and play the 18 on Wednesday early, I could catch a
flight to get me back to Boston in the afternoon. Assignment for Tuesday early!
Old Elm Golf Club, July 18,
2017: This is a superb club and course. Period, full stop.
Designed by H. S. Colt in
collaboration with Donald Ross in 1913, Ross ended up overseeing the
construction. The list of Colt courses
around the world that included important input from Colt include the likes of
Pine Valley, Milwaukee, Muirfield, Sunningdale—New, Royal County Down, and
Royal Portrush. The course was restored
lovingly between 2010 and 2013 with changes including removal of overgrown
trees, replacing cross bunkers that had been removed in prior years, and
restoring the “Redan” design of the short par 3 17th hole.
Old Elm is one of the most
exclusive clubs in the country (and as mentioned earlier, is restricted to
men). The clubhouse is as simple,
understated, and beautiful as any I have had the pleasure of entering. And trust me, this club is private…if you
doubt that, just go to its website which reveals physical address, phone # ands
fax #, period full stop. No pretty
pictures and glowing history
About 4-5 years ago, I played
with an Old Elm member (Michael M.) at Brookline (as a favor to another member
of Brookline who had to be out of town).
Michael had invited me to come to Chicago to play it, and I was of
course way too busy with my bucket lists.
Then earlier this year, Old Elm made the Golf Week USA Classic Top 100
list (note…but not my merged Top 100 list), and since one of my bucket lists is
to complete all 200 of the GW 2016 and 2017 Classic and Modern lists, it made
it to my priority planning list. The bad
news was that Michael was tied up that morning and could not join me. But we were able to have dinner later that
evening and his wife Suzanne joined us late into the dinner.
Let me just say that how this
place has not made a Top 100 is a condemnation of all USA ratings. Part of the reason of course is the
exclusivity of the course, and it probably had been kept off some lists because
not enough raters had played it. I would
put it about #50-60 in the USA (unfortunately I played it exactly 4 days after
the cut off for my 2017 Golf Magazine ballot).
Old Elm--my caddy pointed to the sky and said "Church Pews in the sky" |
The golf course that is the
piece de la resistance (spelling???)!
Here again, simple elegance rules, even down to the ball washers (should
have taken a picture!). Big wide
fairways can fool you into thinking you can hit it anywhere. You can, of course, it’s just that you might
leave yourself no shot on your approach…just like with the game of pool and The
Old Course…you need to play each shot with the next one in mind. The bunkering here is simple and simply superb. The conditioning is something to behold…firm
and fast (a little too green but fairly understandable since they received
about 5” of rain in about 2 hours one week earlier).
The best part of the course
is the double green shared by the par 5 6th and par 3 17th
holes. This may be the coolest green I
have ever seen (or tied with #16 at North Berwick). It is a double green, has a Biarritz “valley”
separating the two halves of the green, and the 17th green is also a
Redan! See picture below.
Old Elm Double Green 6-17 w Biarritz valley separating...6th pin in foreground and 17th just to right of big tree in background; 17th tee toward far left. |
This remains a hidden gem…if
you get the chance…play it!!
Given the weather forecast,
decided to see if I could play 54 today.
So upon leaving Old Elm, headed straight to Conway Farms.
Conway Farms, July 18, 2017: Conway Farms was completed in 1991 and
designed by Tom Fazio. It is situated in
Lake Forest, IL on a 209-acre site.
During is relatively short time it has hosted a series of important
events, including the 1997 NCAA Division I Men’s Championships, 2009 Western
Amateur, 2012 US Mid-Amateur, and 2013/15/17 BMW Championship (part of the Fed
Exp playoffs). With some 8 weeks
remaining before play commences at the 2017 BMW, the club was a virtually hub
of construction activity, with grandstands already well under
construction. While it appeared on the
GW USA Modern Top 100 from 1998-2001. it was never rated high enough to make a
USA “merged” Top 100; and it has not appeared on a GD or GM Top 100.
I was originally scheduled to
play it with my host, Keith B., an Executive Producer of the movie Tommy’s
Honor (see post from early May, 2017), however, Keith’s back has been given him
fits and he has been unable to play. I
arrived hoping to be able to get out early, but discovered that the course was
closed until 11am due to maintenance in the morning (in preparation for the
BMW). The head pro (Andrew Adamsick) was
super accommodating, allowing me to tee off on #3, play 16 holes and then play
#1-2. This worked superbly, as the first
tee was totally deserted when we finished #18 and we were able to get right off
and play in about 2:30.
The course has been set up
this year for the upcoming BMS event, so the fairways were fairly narrow and
the rough starting to get thick.
Compared to the wide fairways at Old Elm and Black Sheep it almost felt
like I had walked into a bowling alley.
I played from 5929 yards compared to the tips which total 7233…somewhat
of a different course. I very much liked holes #7 (345 drivable uphill par 4
doglegging left to a two tiered green (which is shallow and wide from the tee
box but deep and narrow from a safely played tee shot), #8 (600 yard par 5
doglegging left around a water hazard to a raised green protected by some extremely deep bunkers in front, and
#11 (177 yard par 3 protected in front by marshes and with a shallow green angles
from front left to back right. I scored
better than I played…39–41 = 80.
Overall, this is a very good
tour course. Given it was set up for an
upcoming event, it was hard to tell how wide its fairways normally are and if
more options and angles come into play.
Those flatbellies certainly play a very different game!!
After the round I thanked
Adam and his staff and quickly headed north to Libertyville, IL and Merit Club.
Merit Club, July 18, 2017: Merit is about 20 miles north of Lake Forest
in Libertyville, IL. It sits on a 320-acre
site and was designed by Ed Oldfield, Sr. (a long time teacher in the Chicago
area) and Bob Lohmann (Canyata and Midlothian).
Merit hosted the 2000 US Woman’s Open.
In 1997 it was rated #98 in the USA by Golf Magazine, and was included
on GW’s USA Modern Top 100 from 1997-2000 (the first 4 years of GW’s listings),
but never high enough to make my merged list.
By playing Merit this day, I completed the Golf Magazine USA Top 100
EVER. As most of you know, last year I
completed GM’s Global Top 100.
Merit is built on a very good
piece of land but frankly the course itself was fairly disappointing,
especially the bunkering. There was very
little that inspired or excited me…not much that was bad, but very little that
was special. Teed off on #11 to avoid
running into some groups and that worked well.
It plays to 7119 yards and I played from 6109 yards and played very well
(37-40 = 77). I think this piece of
land could have yielded to superb course, but as in most fields, the very best
architects do make a difference…and I am not sure that Oldfield and Lohmann fit
that billing.
Was tired at the end of the
round (but actually played my best on the last 7 holes I played…one under
par). Was good to get back to
hotel. Also was able to change my tee time
at Wynstone for the next morning and move up my flight…be great to get home in
afternoon rather that late at night! And
thunderstorm threat much diminished, so good fortune continued (knock on wood).
Wynstone Country Club, July
19, 2017: I had moved my tee time up to 7:20am (from
1:30pm) and arrived at the club at 6:40am, which turned out to be a very good
thing! Turns out the change in my time
never got posted to the tee sheet, but the assistant pro pushed me up to 6:55am
so that I would be the first out.
Wynstone CC is a Jack
Nicklaus signature design located on the former family estate of W. Clement
Stone. Stone grew up in a poor family
and built a huge insurance company. He lived
to be 100 years of age. The course opened
for play in 1989 and winds through real estate.
Was renovated in 2015. It plays
to 7162 yards, par 72 (I played from 5946).
Water comes into play on 12 holes (and potentially on 2 others), and the
course is very difficult if you start spraying tee shots. These days I hit it pretty straight (don’t
hit it long enough to reach the trouble), so was able to avoid the water and
shot a solid 38-40 = 78. Zipped around
in 1:55!!
The course was rated #85 in
Golf Digest’s 1993 USA Top 100. Never
appeared on any other Top 100 rating.
Most of the holes are surrounded by housing and the player has very
little feel for the overall flow of the course on most holes. Simply put, as I finished 18, I was not wishing
I had the time to do it again. I was
pleased to get this one behind me.
Thanked the staff members who
helped, and was off to O’Hare Airport and an on time flight home. Pat on the other hand had to deal with a flat
tire, so she got home after me.
As always…was great to see
her and be back home. And my to do list
to conquer my multiple bucket lists was down to 41. Had one day to rest prior to the Brookline
Club Championship (Super Senior Division) Friday through Sunday…and then was
scheduled hit the road again 7/24-26…five more courses in MI and OH.